ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
3179951128
ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
Back to search
IN
Marion
Indianapolis
morton place
46202
Search similar
IN
Marion
Indianapolis
morton place
46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Newly Listed
48 Photos
Unsave
Save

$775,000

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202

ACTIVE
48 Photos
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Unsave
Save
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202

Information

Price: $775,000
Days On Market: 1
Year Build: 2008
Square Footage: 3,351 Sq ft
Total Baths: 4
Full Baths: 3
Half Baths: 1
Bedrooms: 4
MLS ID: 22094242
Status: Active

Details

Address: 2026 N New Jersey Street
County: Marion
City: Indianapolis
Neighborhood: morton place
Zip: 46202
State: Indiana

Taxes

Tax Year: 2025

Description

Nestled on the iconic esplanade in historic Herron Morton Place, this custom-built 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home offers the perfect blend of timeless neighborhood charm and modern luxury. Known for its vibrant porch parties and beloved Oktoberfest celebration, this highly sought-after community delivers an unmatched lifestyle just steps from Herron Morton Park. Enjoy walkability to local favorites like Tinker Street, Foundry Provisions, Baby's, Loco, and Mashcraft Brewery, while remaining just a short 5-10 minute drive to downtown hospitals, Eli Lilly, and Salesforce. Nearby top-rated schools include Herron High School, CFI 27, and The Oaks Academy. Inside, the home features a rare main-floor primary suite, along with a thoughtfully designed layout that includes a separate dining room, dedicated laundry room, powder bath, and an expansive kitchen that opens seamlessly to the living area with a cozy gas fireplace. Step out back to relax on the screened-in porch complete with a hot tub and tranquil water feature-perfect for entertaining or unwinding. A covered walkway connects the spacious 3-car garage to the home's rear entry, leading into a functional mudroom/office space. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized bedrooms with large closets and a full bathroom. The finished basement offers incredible additional living space, featuring a projector and screen for movie nights, a separate storage room ideal for a wine cellar, a workout room, bonus space, and a full bedroom with a large walk-in closet and full bath. This exceptional property combines location, space, and unique features rarely found in Herron Morton Place-truly a must-see.

Location

Listed By

Listing Agent

Kate Tuttle

kate@atpropertiesind.com
@properties

Similar Listings

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$765,000
801 Silverleaf Drive, Greenwood, IN, 46143
4
4
5,679 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22063518

Listing Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro S

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$660,000
4956 S W County Road 230, Greensburg, IN, 47240
4
3
5,258 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095250

Listing Office: Woolum Real Estate, LLC

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$886,000
4155 S Walnut Street Pike, Bloomington, IN, 47401
4
3
3,036 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22046872

Listing Office: Sweet Maple Realty

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$675,000
3520 Middle Patton Park Road, Martinsville, IN, 46151
4
3
4,280 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095753

Listing Office: F.C. Tucker Company

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$820,000
7716 S Patton Road, Bloomington, IN, 47401
4
3
3,561 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22068024

Listing Office: Eagle Pointe Realty

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$799,000
4873 Austin Trace, Zionsville, IN, 46077
4
5
4,840 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22068559

Listing Office: Compass Indiana, LLC

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$773,890
6850 W S County Road 25, Greencastle, IN, 46135
4
4
3,354 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22089768

Listing Office: Brick & Ivy Realty

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$675,000
15618 Temple Wood Circle, Fishers, IN, 46037
4
3
3,194 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22078704

Listing Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$700,000
7254 Merriam Road, Indianapolis, IN, 46240
4
3
3,711 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22084906

Listing Office: F.C. Tucker Company

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$825,000
115 Lynn Court, Zionsville, IN, 46077
4
4
3,657 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22085283

Listing Office: United Real Estate Indpls

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$699,900
17170 Hearthfield Way, Noblesville, IN, 46062
4
4
3,113 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095803

Listing Office: eXp Realty, LLC

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$750,000
640 E 10th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
4
4
2,146 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22092395

Listing Office: @properties

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$779,900
4201 W State Road 234, Mccordsville, IN, 46055
4
3
6,780 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22084524

Listing Office: F.C. Tucker Company

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$700,000
771 Mikal Lane, Brownsburg, IN, 46112
4
5
6,142 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22077569

Listing Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$689,900
11704 Gray Eagle Drive, Fishers, IN, 46037
4
3
4,487 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22082108

Listing Office: Triple E Realty, LLC

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$799,900
2602 N Delaware Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46205
4
4
3,352 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22082095

Listing Office: Maywright Property Co.

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$724,900
6259 Stone Side Drive, Plainfield, IN, 46168
4
4
3,286 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22074327

Listing Office: Drees Home

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$865,000
118 White Horse Lane, Fishers, IN, 46038
4
5
5,915 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22080233

Listing Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz

2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$850,000
1546 E Osprey Drive, Greenfield, IN, 46140
4
5
3,986 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22063193

Listing Office: RE/MAX Realty Group

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$699,986
14279 Hidden Lakes Drive, Noblesville, IN, 46060
4
4
3,817 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22070216

Listing Office: Weekley Homes Realty Company

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$785,000
14322 Cumberland Road, Noblesville, IN, 46060
4
3
3,714 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22085352

Listing Office: Berkshire Hathaway Home

Newly Listed
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$779,900
3820 N SR 75, Thorntown, IN, 46071
4
4
4,304 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22093789

Listing Office: RE/MAX Edge

Newly Listed
Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$875,000
8446 E Parkview Drive, Rockville, IN, 47872
4
3
2,565 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095915

Listing Office: Hoosier Roots Real Estate Solutions, LLC

Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$749,900
12786 Tuscany Boulevard, Carmel, IN, 46032
4
4
4,367 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22081093

Listing Office: Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Newly Listed
Virtual Tour
2026 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
$799,900
7050 Wildridge Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46256
4
3
4,912 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095113

Listing Office: Mike Watkins Real Estate Group

No similar listings found

Unfortunately, we don't have any similar listings at the moment. Please remove or change some of the selected filters.
Print Details
Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. Updated: 24th April, 2026 11:17 PM (UTC)
Listing Office: @properties
Attribution contact:

kate@atpropertiesind.com

Have a question?

SEND
Submitting
Succes! Your message was sent!
Oops! Error occurred.

About me

inception-app-prod/MmY5M2U1OGEtMGFhMS00OGJkLWEyMDAtZmRlYWNkNmM2YmQx/logo/2018/08/Elisabeth Lugar Fishers Realtor CU 2 %281%29.jpg
Elisabeth "Beth" Lugar
REALTOR® serving Home Buyers and Sellers in Central Indiana
Trusted Central Indiana REALTOR®
M: (317) 995-1128
E: elugar@c21scheetz.com

Mortgage calculator

Calculate

Your monthly rate would be:

$0.00
Created with Placester

Cookie policy

We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By continuing to use this site, you agree to the use of cookies.
Accept
Decline