ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
3179951128
ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
ELISABETH LUGAR TRUSTED CENTRAL INDIANA REALTOR 317-995-1128 logo
BUY SELL LOVE INDIANAPOLIS
Back to search
IN
Henry
New Castle
no subdivision
47362
Search similar
IN
Henry
New Castle
no subdivision
47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
25 Photos
Unsave
Save

$119,900

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362

PENDING
25 Photos
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
Unsave
Save
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362

Information

Price: $119,900
Days On Market: 78
Year Build: 1900
Square Footage: 2,806 Sq ft
Total Baths: 2
Full Baths: 2
Bedrooms: 4
MLS ID: 22074430
Status: Pending

Nearby Schools

Eastwood Elementary SchoolElementary School
New Castle Middle SchoolMiddle School
New Castle High SchoolHigh School

Details

Address: 1727 Plum Street
County: Henry
City: New Castle
Neighborhood: no subdivision
Zip: 47362
State: Indiana

Taxes

Tax Year: 2025

Description

This versatile home, originally designed as a duplex, offers the potential for easy conversion back to its original layout. Situated on a corner lot, the property features a fenced yard and a generous 3+ car detached garage with attic storage, ensuring ample space for vehicles and belongings. With off-street parking available, this residence can accommodate up to 6 bedrooms or provide abundant flexible living spaces. There are 2 full bathrooms and a large kitchen, perfect for gatherings. Enjoy the convenience of a basement, a covered front porch, and a nice utility/laundry area located on the main level. Recent updates include newer flooring in several areas, along with hardwood floors in others. The main floor offers 1 or 2 bedrooms, and the home features two stairways.

Location

Listed By

Listing Agent

Susan Falck-Neal

susan@susanfalckneal.com
RE/MAX First Integrity

Similar Listings

Virtual Tour
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$113,000
1027 W 11th Street, Anderson, IN, 46016
4
2
1,178 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22065671

Listing Office: RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$109,900
621 E 31st Street, Anderson, IN, 46016
4
1
1,714 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22041323

Listing Office: Highgarden Real Estate

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$119,999
2845 W 3rd Avenue, Clinton, IN, 47842
4
1
2,540 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22057428

Listing Office: Beycome Brokerage Realty LLC

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$110,900
2806 N Denny Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46218
4
3
1,886 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22060516

Listing Office: List With Ben, LLC

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$105,000
198 S Washington Street, Hagerstown, IN, 47346
4
2
2,816 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22064177

Listing Office: Beycome Brokerage Realty LLC

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$126,580
1621 Union Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46225
4
1
2,262 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22065114

Listing Office: Kenter Real Estate, LLC

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$119,900
4014 Richelieu Road, Indianapolis, IN, 46226
4
2
1,872 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095648

Listing Office: Trelora Realty

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$107,000
1265 W 34th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46208
4
2
1,564 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22097350

Listing Office: Elite Indy Realty Group

Virtual Tour
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$129,900
2835 Baltimore Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46218
4
1
1,104 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22090748

Listing Office: Trelora Realty

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$105,000
4603-4605 E Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46201
4
2
2,745 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22090826

Listing Office: Realty Wealth Advisors

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$135,000
911 W 3rd Street, Anderson, IN, 46016
4
1
2,492 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22089749

Listing Office: Inspired Realty

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$115,500
204 E Pennsylvania Street, Shelbyville, IN, 46176
4
2
2,202 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22094064

Listing Office: Red Bridge Real Estate

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$115,000
709 Broad Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
4
2
2,256 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22070997

Listing Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®

Virtual Tour
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$119,200
212 E Hopewell Street, Farmersburg, IN, 47850
4
2
1,985 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22074354

Listing Office: eXp Realty, LLC

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$119,900
1051 N Holmes Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46222
4
1
2,218 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22074208

Listing Office: Barron Property Services

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$118,500
2005 N Bancroft Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46218
4
2
1,296 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22079129

Listing Office: Everhart Studio, Ltd.

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$135,000
1546 Hoefgen Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46203
4
1
1,276 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22089047

Listing Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro S

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$124,900
402 S Franklin Street, Darlington, IN, 47940
4
1
1,040 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22086265

Listing Office: Keller Williams-Morrison

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$129,900
1738 N Parker Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46218
4
2
1,736 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22085515

Listing Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$134,900
203 Crane Drive, Crawfordsville, IN, 47933
4
2
2,082 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22087983

Listing Office: Keller Williams-Morrison

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$124,900
2822 Baltimore Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46218
4
2
1,147 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22095679

Listing Office: Go Fish Realty

Newly Listed
Virtual Tour
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$120,000
1817 Jefferson Street, Anderson, IN, 46016
4
2
1,610 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22095369

Listing Office: RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$122,000
3545 Orange Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46203
4
2
1,104 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22091727

Listing Office: JRB Group

Newly Listed
1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$115,000
1137 N Courtland Avenue, Kokomo, IN, 46901
4
2
2,198 Sq ft
ACTIVE
MLS# 22100106

Listing Office: F.C. Tucker Company

1727 Plum Street, New Castle, IN, 47362
$134,900
9925 Catalina Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235
4
1
1,467 Sq ft
PENDING
MLS# 22090730

Listing Office: Matlock Realty Group

No similar listings found

Unfortunately, we don't have any similar listings at the moment. Please remove or change some of the selected filters.
Print Details
Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. Updated: 12th May, 2026 8:55 AM (UTC)
Listing Office: RE/MAX First Integrity
Attribution contact:

susan@susanfalckneal.com

Have a question?

SEND
Submitting
Succes! Your message was sent!
Oops! Error occurred.

About me

inception-app-prod/MmY5M2U1OGEtMGFhMS00OGJkLWEyMDAtZmRlYWNkNmM2YmQx/logo/2018/08/Elisabeth Lugar Fishers Realtor CU 2 %281%29.jpg
Elisabeth "Beth" Lugar
REALTOR® serving Home Buyers and Sellers in Central Indiana
Trusted Central Indiana REALTOR®
M: (317) 995-1128
E: elugar@c21scheetz.com

Mortgage calculator

Calculate

Your monthly rate would be:

$0.00
Created with Placester

Cookie policy

We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By continuing to use this site, you agree to the use of cookies.
Accept
Decline